spoilery meat!
So
dafstar commented to me that Dumbledore getting killed by someone he trusted (and was trying to call on to help him) right after telling Draco about the possibility of faking his death to escape is perhaps a bit too coincidental.
I think Dumbledore really is dead. Why? I wouldn't be surprised if there was a plan but it all went wrong.
Faked-death-gone-wrong scenario one: Snape and Dumbledore had planned to fake Dumbledore's death, but the Unbreakable vow made Snape actually kill him. Dumbledore didn't see this coming until Snape walked in the room and it was too late. Between this and Potter's presence, Snape cracked.
Faked-death-gone-wrong scenario two: Snape and Dumbledore had planned to fake Dumbledore's death, only Snape was going to really go through with it when the time came. Dumbledore didn't see this coming until Snape walked in the room and it was obvious.
So
dafstar commented to me that Dumbledore getting killed by someone he trusted (and was trying to call on to help him) right after telling Draco about the possibility of faking his death to escape is perhaps a bit too coincidental.I think Dumbledore really is dead. Why? I wouldn't be surprised if there was a plan but it all went wrong.
Faked-death-gone-wrong scenario one: Snape and Dumbledore had planned to fake Dumbledore's death, but the Unbreakable vow made Snape actually kill him. Dumbledore didn't see this coming until Snape walked in the room and it was too late. Between this and Potter's presence, Snape cracked.
Faked-death-gone-wrong scenario two: Snape and Dumbledore had planned to fake Dumbledore's death, only Snape was going to really go through with it when the time came. Dumbledore didn't see this coming until Snape walked in the room and it was obvious.
Profile
- bovil
- Andrew Trembley
- The Bovine Illuminati
Comments
Snape threw an Avada Kedavra at Dumbledore. So far, nobody has ever survived that curse except Harry. Dumbledore didn't have any physical objects to throw in the way, he didn't have Fawkes to block for him, and he didn't have his wand. I don't see any way of him getting out of it.
If Draco's task was to kill Dumbledore (pretty high chance) and the Unbreakable Vow made Snape take on the task, I don't think Snape could have faked it either. There's always the chance of a loophole, but I didn't see much of one.
So...
Unbreakable Vow + Avada Kedavra + wand-less Dumbledore = dead